What would you do if...

[narniagirl11]

Capture it! And bribe it and pet it until it was nice.

WWYDI the giant Rumblebuffin appeared outside your door?

[Ariel.of.Narnia]

Wonder why I didn't hear or feel him coming.

WWYDI you woke up with Reep standing on your chest and pointing a sword at your face?

[narniagirl11]

Quote Flynn Rider! "Well I hope you're here to apologize!"

WWYDI Susan offered to let you borrow one of her really pretty dresses?

[Ariel.of.Narnia]

That... was a brilliant answer. Just putting that out there.
Uh, take it, duh.

WWYDI Reep cornered you for stealing an orange?

[narniagirl11]

Pull out another Flynn quote. "What? I bought it! Most of it."

WWYDI you accidentally knocked Peter's sword overboard?

[Ariel.of.Narnia]

I think someone's been watching Tangled....
Panic.

WWYDI you had to spend the summer at pre-dragon Eustace's?

[elanorelle]

I'd try to find a painting of a ship so that we could go on an adventure in Narnia where he would turn into a dragon and then change back, but as a nicer person.

WWYDI you met a star?

[narniagirl11]

Ask he/she what it's like!

WWYDI the Eastern Ocean suddenly dried up?

[Ariel.of.Narnia]

First, I'd revert into a cartoon character and have over my head.
Then make this face:
Then this face:
Then pull a Boromir and ask, "What new devilry is this?"

WWYDI you were present when Caspian got information/stories about the Eastern Ocean from the old salts?

[narniagirl11]

Make a funny face like this and walk away.

WWYDI you were bringing a silver apple back to Aslan, but you lost it right before you were about to present it to him?