Ask it if it could talk (although many cats can give intellegent looks without talking...)
WWYDI you knew where the rings were, but knew you would have to go through a lot of hard things to get them?
Depends on the "hard things". 🙂 Probably not risk it though....
WWYDI you were woken by an owl tapping on your window?
Get up and go to it!
WWYDI you found THE wardrobe in you basement?
Ask how on earth it got there without my knowing about it! And then open it. That's kind of a given. 😀
WWYDI you found yourself alone in Polly's "smuggler's cave"?
Want to read her story, but not do it. (I understand her not wanting to show it to Digory before it was finished.)
WWYDI you found a very cool-looking silver-colored chair at a furniture store?
Want it.
WWYDI you came home one day to find out that the Extreme Makeover guys had been by and made your house Narnian?
Squee. And wonder what my parents will say.
WWYDI you came across a group of fauns dancing in the woods?
Watch. And film them if at all possible.
WWYDI a hag tapped you on the shoulder in the middle of a large crowd?
Uh, scream...?
WWYDI you found and then lost Lucy's cordial?
Cry probably.
WWYDI you found Rhindon, but it was reeeeeeaaaally old and rusty and would need very expensive restoration?
Try to make enough money to restore it to it's glory. Wouldn't be a bad investment in my eyes. 😉
WWYDI you came across a bell and hammer (magical or not magical? Striking it would be the only way to find out) and no one was around?
Uh...probably grab a sword or some other weapon, and then hit the bell lightly with the hammer. And keep my eyes peeled for witches popping out of nowhere suddenly or waxworks coming to life.
WWYDI Reepicheep challenged you to go onto the Dark Island with him?
Refuse and cause detriment to whatever honour I have and refuse again. (One particular nightmare I hope to never have again, even if I did turn out to be the hero.)
WWYDI your sibling betrayed you to the White Witch?
Um...be mad at them? (And you're soooooo lucky that in your nightmare you were the hero in the end! I'm always just the failure main character. Like Caspian. 😛 )
WWYDI you had to fight in a battle you really, really, really did not want to be in?
(Maybe so, but I still woke up in a muck sweat, it scared me that badly.)
My actions would be determined by why I didn't want to fight in the first place, but I'd probably end up dying not far into it.
WWYDI your sibling ran back into your house during an air raid?