Call the police. 😛
WWYDI you met a friend who was now older than you?
"Hi..." *thinking* This is awkward...
WWYDI Reep told you to push?
Be very honored. And definitely frame it.
WWYDI you looked out your window and saw a Dufflepud?
Call him a liar. (My mom doesn't store much candy in her cupboards. 😛 )
WWYDI you went to a banquet and found three sleeping men at the table of honour?
Get all bugeyed.
WWYDI you discovered Burnt Island?
Not touch!
WWYDI you saw a flower made out of gold?
Be surprised and ask her what it looked like and help her look for it.
WWYDI you were about to do something perfectly normal and everyday (like sharpening a pencil or opening the fridge) and saw a roosting phoenix watching you very closely?
Be creeped out.
WWYDI you heard of an island nation of Telmarines?
Wonder why and hope I wasn't going batty.
WWYDI a faun offered to play his flute to help you fall asleep?