Be incredulous that Lewis, of all people, would plan to write a romance between a (I believe) twelve and thirteen year old.
WWDI you got lost in Tashbaan?
Be extremely glad he didn't (just as I was relieved that he didn't go with Aragorn/Eowyn).
WWYDI you found out Peter pursued a career in medicine?
Spree's: Be very scared.
Ariel's: Laugh at the irony.
WWYDI you found out the Green Mist was real?
Cool! And hope I don't fall off the roof. 😀
WWYDI you saw a winged horse casually grazing in a farmer's pasture?
O_O "Something is very wrong with this picture...."
WWYDI you found out that, somewhere under your house, there are the remains of a Dwarfish forge?
Be scandalized.
WWYDI you found out that Mr Tumnus was a pro at cake decorating?
Shake my head and point out again that female villains are the worst.
WWYDI Narnians abducted you?
Be very frightened.
WWYDI you thought you saw Centaurs on the horizon?
Well that's not an issue since I live in the UK 😛
WWYDI the duffers asked you to read from the magic book.