"Sorry to disappoint you, but I don't think I did."

WWYDI Susan asked you to help her play matchmaker for one of her brothers?

Prooooooooooooooooobably mess everything up...

WWYDI you turned into a Dufflepud overnight?

*jawdrop*

WWYDI a mermaid introduced herself to you?

Be excited! And try to talk o.o

WWYDI you were left behind in Tashbaan after the Narnians sailed back to Cair Paravel?

Try to escape with Cor and Aravis!

WWYDI you were offered a ride by and on a Unicorn?

Party!! --and accept it.

WWYDI your painting of Aslan looked like it roared at you from the corner of your eye?

whip around and stare

WWYDI you saw Jill pop out of a hill in your area?

*jawdrop*

WWYDI a star person descended in front of you?

Either freak out or-- nah, most definitely freak out. 😛

WWYDI you learned that "Many sink down in to Underworlds, but few return to sunlit lands" was an actual password for some secret organization?

Laugh.

WWYDI you got lost in Anvard?

Try to get un-lost... and enjoy it a lot, considering it's --well, it's Anvard! 😉

WWYDI somebody smashed your Silver Chair?

"Dude! That was vintage!! I demand that you pay for the repair work!" (... yeah, I'd totally love to have a silver chair)

WWYDI you found out that one of the islands the Dawn Treader visited was populated by mutant cheese curls?

*facepalm*

WWYDI you got kidnapped by evil giants?

Probably scream 😯

WWYDI you got lost in Lantern Waste?

Try to find Tumnus.

WWYDI a girl saw you and screamed and hid behind a lamppost?