the former!
WYR travel to the Eastern End of the World or to the Garden in the West?
The garden!
WYR gooooo wayyyy south to Calormen or go waaaay north to Ettinsmoor?
Thank you, Hobbit!
Ettinsmoor
WYR get lost in Tashbaan or Harfang?
Tashbaan. At least everything else is normal-sized.
WYR hunt the White Stag or watch Corin box the lapsed Bear?
Ooh, tough one. I'll go with the Stag.
WYR swim in the Sunless Sea (I think that's what it's called... 😕 ) or Cauldron Pool?
Cauldron Pool!!
WYR have named the Silver Sea as Lily Lake or..... er, the Silver Sea?
Thank you, Hobbit!
Silver Sea
WYR read a fanfic that pairs Edmund or Lucy with an OC?
Edmund. Cause I'm weird like that.
WYR read a Peter/OC or a Suspian story?
YOU IS TALKING IN FANFIC LANGUAGE OR SOMETHING.
WYR be chosen as an actor for LB or director of HHB? (when/if they ever make them)
Thank you, Hobbit!
Actor for LB! Totally!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Actually....Maybe the director......Nah! I love HHB and I would love to direct it, buuuuuuuuuuuuuut you just can't let a chance like acting LB go!!!
WYR go back in time and change (The book) PC or SC?
Hrrrrrm, SC, I guess?
WYR try der apple-bearmeat dumplings that Trumpkin made in PC, or the pigeon-herb-whatever stew Poggin made in LB? 
Thank you, Hobbit!
They both sound so good... but I think the stew would be more flavourful.
WYR hide out with Tirian in the tower or with Caspian in the woods?
Tower..... Rrrr. We likes roofs.
WYR meet Phillip or Bree?
Thank you, Hobbit!
Philip
WYR spend an afternoon with Mr or Mrs Beaver?
Mrs. Beaver.
WYR see Tumnus' Cave or Beaversdam?
Thank you, Hobbit!
