Probably 145.

WYR eat something really sugary or really spicy?

Sugary!

WYR read an AU fanfic or a romantic (canon/OC) one?

Depends on various factors. I usually keep away from both, but I have read good stories of both category. But since WilliwDryad does more romance than she does AU, I'll say romance. (Even though I'm more accepting of Lucy/Darreth than I am of Peter/Linnet. 😛 )

WYR explore Ramandu's Island or the ruins of Cair Paravel?

( 😛 Me too, about the L/D vs. P/L.)

The Cair!

WYR visit Archenland or the Lone Islands?

I'm going to risk it with the Lone Islands, because in this world, I'd like to visit England and Scotland again as well as Ireland....

WYR have Puddleglum or Trumpkin cook for you out in the wild?

Trumpkin. I don't think I'd like eel.

WYR wear a scarf or a hat?

Might depend. I'm not a fan of stuff on my head, but I'm not a fan of stuff around my neck either. I'll say hat. Less likely to get too hot. 🙂

WYR learn how to shoot a gun or a crossbow?

Crossbow.

WYR use a sword or lightsaber? (Yes, I'm turning into a SW geek. 🙄 )

Sword. (In the SW universe, I'd take a vibrosword with cortosis-weave.)

WYR buy a personalized item for someone or something from one of their fandoms?

Fandoms.

WYR make brownies or cookies?

Cookies

WYR eat cake or pie?

Cake.

WYR have strawberry or chocolate ice cream?

Chocolate.

Pink Peppermint or Green Creme De Menthe?

Creme de Menthe!

WYR eat cookie dough or a pazookie?

Pazookie.

WYR listen to happy or sad music?