Ginger bread.

WYR sing classic Christmas carols/hymns or contemporary Christmas songs?

Classic.

WYR wrap a present or put it in a bag with tissue paper?

Wrap it.

WYR put up Christmas lights or decorate the tree?

Decorate the tree.

WYR spend Christmas Day with your immediate family or with your extended family?

Immediate.

WYR attend a candlelight service or watch a Christmas pageant?

Christmas pageant
WYR drink hot chocolate with candycanes or marshmallows?

Marshmallows!

WYR lose your boots or your gloves while sledding? 😛 Both happened to me today, and at the same time. 😆

I haven't sled in a LONG time (no snow here) but I think I'd rather lose my gloves. 😛

WYR ride a pony or a horse?

Horse all the way.

WYR play a shepherd or an angel in a Christmas play?

Shepherd.

WYR ride in a coach/hansom or sleigh?

Sleigh!

WYR believe in Father Christmas or Santa Claus?

Neither, I'll go for the Father of Christ. 🙂

WYR wake up really early or sleep in really late on Christmas morning?

Sleep in. ^.^

WYR put a gift in a bag or wrap it?

bag

WYR participate in a secret Santa or a "Chinese" gift exchange?

Secret santa

WYR watch a Christmas play or be in one?